
I own a
Nook e-reader from Barnes & Noble that was a gift purchased at Best Buy. About a week ago, I started seeing lines on the screen, so I planned to bring it to Best Buy for repair or replacement.
Wednesday, Rebecca and I were taking Olivia to the beach, so I brought the Nook along to make a stop at the Port Arthur store, since we'd be nearby.
I had my receipt in hand and spoke to the lady at the service counter. She was very friendly and legitimately looking for a way to help me.
Since I didn't purchase a protection plan, she recommend I talk to Geek Squad and see what my options were, and assumed that the 1-year manufacturers warranty would repair my Nook, but they'd likely need to send it away for repairs, leaving me without the device for at least a week or more.
I asked her if an even exchange was possible, so she took my receipt to give it a try. Because I purchased the Nook in February, June was far outside the return policy, but to my surprise, the system would allow an exchange. Unfortunately, there were no Nook readers in stock.
Apparently, Barnes & Noble is releasing a new version, causing the current stock to deplete. According to her computer, there was one available at the Beaumont location.
I thanked her for the help, and left planning to stop by the other location for my exchange. This would be a lot quicker than waiting for the repair to be shipped, fixed, and returned.
The next day, I stopped by the Beaumont location with my receipt, Nook, and power adapter hoping for an easy in-and-out exchange. This would not be the case.
For starters, the item I needed wasn't in stock, meaning I would have to send the product in for repair, or exchange it for in-store credit.
The girl at the register seemed genuine, but said the computer would not process my exchange since it was outside the window for returns or exchanges. I explained that the location in Port Arthur would allow the exchange, and after a brief conversation with her supervisor, she told me I was out of luck and would need to go to Port Arthur for the exchange.
I got the impression she thought I was trying to pull a fast one and was calling my bluff. The broken Nook sitting on the counter apparently wasn't enough for her to believe I had a legitimate problem.
I asked about repairing the device with the manufacturers warranty, but she was also unable to help, saying I needed to contact Barnes & Noble directly. When I mentioned the Port Arthur store recommended I go through Geek Squad, she replied that I could try it, but she didn't know.
At this point, my options are to (1) talk to Geek Squad about repairing the device, (2) ask to speak to her supervisor, but since she said "no" in the beginning, I didn't believe she'd be much help, or (3) return to Port Arthur for the exchange.
I decided I'd travel back to Port Arthur.
After the 20 minute drive, I spoke to the same girl from the day before and explained to her what happened in Beaumont. She rolled her eyes at the ridiculousness of the story, processed my receipt for the exchange, and (since they were still out of stock), gave me a Best Buy gift card for the amount of the original purchase.
I was out the door in 3 minutes.
Since there wasn't a Nook in stock, I decided I'll wait until the next generation hits stores. While I could get mine repaired, it was buggy and a bit clunky.
I imagine they have customers who try to take advantage of the system causing them to by cynical, but I had both a receipt from the original purchase, and a Nook that clearly showed it wasn't readable from the lines on the screen.
When the girl in Port Arthur told me an exchange was possible (causing me to bypass the long wait for the repair from the manufacturer), and the store nearby had the product in stock, it was a no-brainer. Unfortunately, Beaumont wasn't willing to play nice.
It's odd that the same system from different locations would process my receipt differently. Rather it's true or not, something felt 'fishy' about the situation.
Because she was extremely helpful, I will be sending a gift card from my restaurant and a 'thank you' note to the girl in Port Arthur. Also, when the new Nook is released, I will purchase it from her store, as well.
This is both the good and bad from these big box companies - they make corporate policies that allow returns or exchanges very easily, reducing the hassle for the consumer. However, some of your employees are willing to do the right thing for the customer, while some aren't.
I don't believe the girl in Beaumont (or even her supervisor for that matter) was trying to give poor customer service, I believe they were following policy. Unfortunately, that policy just caused this buyer to travel to the other location for future purchases, because they were willing to do right by the customer.
Since I live in nearby Orange, traveling to Port Arthur or Beaumont means I'm on the road the same amount of time. There is no inconvenience.
Except it doesn't look like the new Nook will be in Best Buy stores anytime soon. There's no word of a release date outside Barnes & Noble. I'm not looking forward to the wait.